Shield of Missile Attraction: does one has to change the attack roll?

I got interested into the cursed item Shield of Missile Attraction, but I have some doubts on how it works. Consider the following scenario:

  • Thurin the Dwarven fighter is walking along the city street, it wears full plate armor and has this cursed shield. Total AC 18.
  • Dalena the Elven mage is just some steps beyond Thurin (hence inside the 10 feet radius). She has a total AC of 15.
  • Greg the thief is planning to kill the mage, from the roof, since she killed his beloved one. He rolls for attack with his crossbow: 16.

Since the fighter has the cursed shield it becomes the target of Greg’s attack. My question is

  • does Greg have to use the original attack roll (16, in this case) because the shield changes only the target? In this case, the attack misses and Thurin does not get hurt.
  • does Greg have to roll another die for the attack? In this case the dwarf may get hit.

The first one seems to be more fair, since the attacker actually does not know that the dart will be deviated towards the owner of the shield.

Attraction Canada

Why are you selling this site?
need more money

How is it monetized?
adsense

Does this site come with any social media accounts?
no

How much time does this site take to run?
it depends

What challenges are there with running this site?
no, wordpress cms is easy to use and maintain

Sale includes:
– Website files and folders
– SQL database
– Domain name

What happens when the wearer of a Shield of Missile Attraction is behind total cover?

The Shield of Missile Attraction, a rare magic item that requires attunement, has the following curse:

Whenever a ranged weapon attack is made against a target within 10 feet of you, the curse causes you to become the target instead.

Say there are two creatures, one (let’s call it A) in clear arrow path and the other (let’s call it B) within 10 feet of A but behind total cover (such as a wall) but also cursed by a Shield of Missile Attraction. What would happen if someone tries to make a ranged weapon attack (such as shooting an arrow) at A?

  1. As there is not a clear arrow path to B, the shield’s Missile Attraction property does not work and A gets shot.
  2. B becomes the target, but the Missile Attraction’s arrow deviation also causes the arrow to somehow go around the wall and B gets shot.
  3. B becomes the target, but the wall takes the arrow so that neither A or B gets shot.
  4. Some other scenario I haven’t envisioned.