Are the instructions given in the “Planar Binding” spell part of the casting time, or can instructions be amended during the spell duration?

The Planar Binding spell is a 5th level abjuration with verbal, somatic and material components and a casting time of 1 hour that allows the target a Charisma saving throw. If the target fails the save, it “must follow your instructions to the best of its ability”.

Are the instructions specified as part of casting the spell? Or are the instructions given after the spell has finished casting? Can instructions be updated/amended throughout the duration of the spell, or is there a one-time period during which the instructions must be fully specified?

Although the duration for the 5th level version of this spell is 24 hours, the duration increases as higher spell slots are used, lasting a year plus a day when a 9th level spell slot is used. I mention this because the longer the spell lasts, the more important the answer to this question becomes.

Can you move during your reaction in a ready action?

So let’s say that the party or the baddies want to dive a target all at once, but they are far apart on the turn order. Can the divers all do a ready action and then all jump in at once?


Turn order is:

  1. PC1
  2. PC2
  3. NPC1
  4. PC3
  5. PC4
  6. NPC2

Can NPC1 do a ready action of “when NPC2 moves in to attack a PC, I move in to attack the same PC” and then move and attack as the reaction?

Freeing Others from Webs During Combat

My players found themselves in a situation where they were mostly webbed by giant spiders. One person was free and asked to cut out one of the restrained players.

Looking up the rules, I don’t see anything about freeing restrained party members. When they went to free their comrade, they asked if they should roll for it. I said no. They were cutting out their party member which expended their action versus using an ability. I thought the action expenditure was enough.

We went with it during the session, but after the fact, I can’t find any rules for freeing trapped party members. Does anyone have clarification on this?

What ways are there to turn during a charge?

I found Charging Stag Style and Sharp Veer in this /r/Pathfinder_RPG thread on Reddit, and thought “Hmm this sounds like fun.” So I was wondering if there are any other ways to get a charge. No rulebook restrictions; 3PP and 3.5e content are allowed on a case-by-case basis, but the answer is yes or compromise like 90% of the time, so just assume it’s allowed.

How do I turn during a charge other than Charging Stag Style and Sharp Veer?

Both of those options work, but each only allows a single turn of up to 90 degrees during your charge; I want those sick 360-degree charges.

Do the targets of Prayer of Healing need to be present during the casting time?

Prayer of Healing has a casting time of 10 minutes. The typical case for this spell would be a cleric casting this on injured members of a party while they rest. But what if one more fellow drops in right before the casting time is done?

That is, do the targets of the spell need to be chosen when the spell casting is started? Or upon completion of the casting time?

Redirect page during a weekly time interval

I have a registration page ‘register’ which sends information to a third party server as part of a dual registration process. The 3rd party have a 2 hr weekly maintenance schedule every Friday 9-11pm CT. I wish to redirect users to a new page that just says you can’t register during this specified maintenance time period.

I am considering using the below added to functions.php. Is this the right approach, does it look like it would work? I don’t want to reset the entire site’s time zone either, as not in America, just for this usage.

add_action ( 'template_redirect', 'redirect_from_registration_maintenance' ); function redirect_from_registration_maintenance(){     date_default_timezone_set('America/Chicago');     $  hour = date('G');     $  minute = date('i');     $  day = date('w');     $  m = $  hour * 60 + $  minute; // Minutes since midnight. if ( !is_user_logged_in() && is_page( 'register' )   && $  day == 5 // Friday...   && $  m >= 1260 // ... after 9pm…   && $  m <= 1380 // ... but before 11pm… ) {     wp_redirect('') ; exit();     } } 


How can my heroic tier PC contribute more during skill challenges?

My character isn’t much use during skill challenges, and the campaign has seen, like, 25% of encounters be skill challenges. I’d like my character to contribute more during skill challenges, whether that’s because my character has more skills he’s trained in or because he’s granting himself or others significant bonuses (i.e. more than +2) or rerolls on skill checks.


Sivart, a human harrier battlemind (Player’s Handbook 3 42—4) with the theme vigilante (Dragon #426 26—7) and the background Aglarond (Forgotten Realms Player’s Guide 76), possesses Str 10, Dex 12, Con 18, Int 8, Wis 16, and Cha 12, and the feats Harrying Step, Heavy Blade Expertise, and Melee Training (Constitution)—the latter two feats being pretty much taxes and the first feeling like one. His languages are Common, Elven, and Goblin. (Besides Common, two other party members speak Elvish and a third speaks Goblin, so Sivart can relay semi-secret messages.) In short, Sivart’s kind of stuck with this class, theme, and background, and those ability scores, feats, and languages. (But see below.)

His trained skills are Bluff, Endurance, Intimidate (the vigilante theme often providing a significant +5 power bonus at level 5 that I don’t want to go to waste), and—due to his background—Perception. I like this skill array, but I’ve found it extremely limited in its applications, making skill challenges more often frustrating than actually challenging.

With Sivart in the mix, the 5-person party is currently trained in every skill except Religion, Streetwise, and Thievery, so being able to make checks competently with those skills is a priority—despite Sivart’s ability scores—both during skill challenges and for everyday use. So you know, the party’s doubled up on the skills Arcana, Endurance, Insight, and Perception, and tripled up on the skill Intimidate. To be clear, Sivart is the only party member trained in the skill Bluff, so him possessing that skill is kind of a big deal. Also, I’d like to keep Sivart trained in the Perception skill to avoid surprises.

Binds and resources

The campaign’s house rules besides those discussed below are irrelevant. (If you’re interested, ask in comments.) For example, feat taxes must be paid, and the Fixed Enhancement Bonus rules (Dark Sun Campaign Setting 209–10) are not used.

  • The homebrew setting is independent of other settings. All official material is available, regardless of the setting for which it’s intended. Setting-specific material’ll be reskinned for the homebrew setting. For instance, despite Sivart’s background saying that he’s from Faerûn, it’d be okay for me to take at level 4 the feat Mark of Warding (Eberron Player’s Guide 92)—it’d just be a unique magic tattoo. (Sorry, Mr. Baker!) I can probably convince the DM to allow third-party material from a reputable publisher but probably not outright homebrew material.
  • The DM’s said that the campaign will likely end when PCs are level 10 but that it could continue afterward. In other words, although Sivart’s feats aren’t spoken for, I’ll likely need one or two feats to firm up my role as the party’s lone defender. Assume that the level 4 feat is available; also assume that either the level 6 or the level 8 feat is available.

  • I find all the level 1 battlemind daily powers uninteresting, although I suspect that won’t matter. I took at level 2 the battlemind utility power feather step (Player’s Handbook 3 46) because Sivart’s a terrible jumper and swimmer, and those’re humiliating ways for an adventurer to die. Still, I’m willing to change that utility power—retraining it upon leveling up—to increase Sivart’s ability to contribute during skill challenges. Further, while I’m eyeing greedily the level 6 utility power psionic ambush (48), I’m willing to let that go, too. Assume that the level 1 daily power and both the level 2 and the level 6 utility powers are available. It may be obvious by now, but encounter powers are preferred over daily powers.

  • Sivart’s three magic items improve only his combat efficacy. The DM—also new to 4e—wants players to submit a wish list of magic items, but I’ve found that reading 4e magic item descriptions makes me want to drink. Also, I’ve not DMed 4e so I don’t yet understand how treasure’s distributed. Answers that also include suggestions for level-appropriate (≤12?) magic items that can help this character during skill challenges are going above and beyond, and that’s welcome. (And—sincerely—thank you!) Most common magic items can be straight-up bought in settlements, but gp is at a premium. (At the mo I have but 18 gp.)
  • The setting—that’s reminiscent of Sword Art Online—allows a character, if in a settlement, to change his build completely for a fee (level squared gp—plus at the DM’s discretion the character’s magic items also change to better complement the new build). Sivart just did this, though. (He was originally a swordsage.) Nonetheless, it can be done again if what needs changing is the background, languages, or another game element that can’t be changed via level-up retraining. (Sivart’d get a loan from the other PCs; this isn’t a big deal.) However, I think race is too integral to change, and the vigilante power mark of the vigilante grants an ability that I think is too good to do without—a stance that allows Sivart to mark a foe until the end of Sivart’s next turn with each successful ranged or melee attack (including an opportunity attack) that he makes—, but I can be convinced.

An example of what I’ve considered

At level 4 I could take the feat Skill Training (Player’s Handbook 201) or—more palatably—a multiclass feat to get Sivart training in the skill Streetwise and retrain the utility power feather step to the skill power secrets of the city (Dragon #389 36). However, only two of the 7 or so skill challenges so far have occurred in a settlement, and to benefit from that power requires Sivart first succeed on a Streetwise skill check in that settlement. Still, this’ll likely be my choice if answers can’t offer a better alternative, especially as it allows substituting Streetwise skill checks for Religion skill checks (after the benefit kicks in, anyway), a skill the party otherwise lacks. If this turns out to be the best option, answers that offer optimal ways for this character to gain training in the Streetwise skill are useful. (To be clear, optimal here means seeing the greatest return for the least investment of resources.)